What’s the Difference? Distinguishing Type 1 from 3, 5, 6, and 8

This next set of posts  contrasts the different Enneagram types that can exhibit common characteristics.  The posts will progress in order from 1 to 9, discussing each type in relation to the specific other types that appear to share similar traits.   This post discusses type 1 (motivation: feel safe; Action Goal: make the world right) in relation to types 3, 5, 6, and 8.

There are circumstances when type 1 people can seem to fit the description for type 3, type 5, type 6 or type 8.  Below are some pointers that clarify what sets type 1 people apart from each of the other types.  

Both 1 and 3 types tend to be organized, result oriented planners who like functioning within a proven, efficient system.  The difference shows up when we look at the relationship between the person and the system.  Type 1 people generally find long-term success in taking on active, invaluable support roles within the system.  In contrast, type 3 people generally feel unsettled and dissatisfied until they reach a central, public, leadership position.  

Both 1 and 5 types can appear opinionated and rigidly confident in their perspectives.  The difference shows up when we look at process by which those opinions and perspectives are formed.  Type 1 people rely on formally recognized information from established, industry data sources.  In contrast, type 5 people rely on their own, individual analysis of data collected from personal experience and observation.

Both 1 and 6 types can find themselves stuck in a state of anxiety.  The difference shows up when we look at the reaction to feeling anxious.  Type 1 people react by seeking and holding onto order and predictability.  In contrast, type 6 people react by becoming more frenetic and dramatic in their multitasking.

Both 1 and 8 types can come across as inflexible and controlling.  The difference shows up when we look at communication style.  Type 1 people will tend to back up their position using formal arguments.  Type 8 people tend towards intimidating language aimed at pressuring the other person into compliance.

Overall, type 1 people are straight shooters who find comfort and resolution in a linear approach to life.